Yay or Nay Wednesday - Faith vs Prada

Faithprada I'm going to tell you where this week's Yay or Nay shoes are from. I have visions of them selling out in the next week and my getting hundreds of emails from Prada fans who want these because they look so much like the pink peep toes we've been raving about for months. So, these are the £45 'Lutton' shoes from Faith...and I want to know if you like 'em or not. Are they a good budget alternative? Or were the Prada ones ugly too? You know the drill, Yay or Nay and why?

Yay or Nay Wednesday - Faith vs Prada - Comments

Susie.

Nay. There's just too much going on. I mean, a peep toe, sling-back /and/ mary-jane style strap? If you took out one of the elements, I would definitely be in love! But right now, they just don't do it for me.

Julia

I do beleive that those pink Prada ones are too "Summer-06": if you buy them now, next season everybody knows they're last-season Prada. so any alternative will be better anyway.

Rachael

These shoes look funny against the white background of this site. But on feet, it's a different matter, and the prada ones certainly look charming. However, I'm NAYing these, because when you have a design as precarious as this, you absolutely CANNOT go cheap. Wearing cheap versions of the avant-garde high-street just never works out well. NAY!

Shuzluva

Nay. I hate the triple combination of peep-toe, mary jane strap and sling back. It's just too much. Without the mary jane strap, they'd be adorable though.