Cheap or Chic Challenge: Cross-front platform pumps

It's time for a long overdue Cheap or Chic Challenge, and this week it's time to cast your votes on these pale coloured platforms. Do you like the lighter heeled numbers on the left, or the contrasting dark and light option on the right? Both of these babies are now reduced in the winter sales, but there's still a difference of $50 between them (originally there was over $100). Which ones do you love the most...and can you guess which are the cheapies? If you know who designed either pair, keep quiet, don't spoil it!

Cheap or Chic Challenge: Cross-front platform pumps - Comments

carson

the plain brown ones are more expensive!

kittya

I prefer those on the right although I guess it is the cheaper one. The brown ones are a bit too plain and unexciting...

Gemma

I much prefer the right ones for some reason, the left ones are just a bit too "brown and bland", I think they are perhaps the cheaper ones and the contrast ones more expensive?

oliviacw

I prefer the one on the right - don't like the brown color of the left, they look too flat. I also think the right one is the more expensive - check out the curve of the heel, versus the very standard heel on the left.