Yay or Nay: Topshop's Lily

Topshop's 'Lily' looks so ugly to me, in fact, that I can only assume it's one of those shoes that looks better on - a bit like Louboutin's Bridget Strass (but unlike it in every other way, of course!) I couldn't find a picture of anyone wearing this shoe, so I'll have to leave the verdict up to you guys. What do you think?